How we score

We use CQC's own scoring method

Not a checklist, and not a percentage of our own invention. The AI assisted audit applies the method CQC publishes today to the evidence you hold.

When CQC changes its approach, we will change with it.

ScoreWhat CQC says it means
1Evidence shows significant shortfalls
2Evidence shows some shortfalls
3Evidence shows a good standard
4Evidence shows an exceptional standard

Source: CQC, How we reach a rating. Wording is CQC's own.

Safe

Illustrative

Quality statements, each scored 1 to 4

Safeguarding
3
Involving people to manage risks
3
Safe environments
4
Safe and effective staffing
3
Medicines optimisation
3
Total 16 of 2080%
Key question ratingGood
Limited by a statement scoring 1

The 1 to 4 scale, in CQC’s words

1 — Evidence shows significant shortfalls

2 — Evidence shows some shortfalls

3 — Evidence shows a good standard

4 — Evidence shows an exceptional standard

The same 1 to 4 scale

Every quality statement scored 1 to 4, as CQC scores them.

The same aggregation

Statement scores roll up to a percentage and a rating for each key question, using CQC's published thresholds.

The same limiting rules

A key question in the good range with any statement scoring 1 is limited to requires improvement. One in the outstanding range with any statement scoring 1 or 2 is limited to good.

Judged in practice, not on paper

The framework tells you what gets assessed. How a finding is actually judged is a separate thing, and that is what the scoring reflects.

The thresholds

At key question level, CQC translates the percentage into a rating.

PercentageKey question rating
88% and aboveOutstanding
63 to 87%Good
39 to 62%Requires improvement
25 to 38%Inadequate

The table starts at 25% because that is the lowest score possible — every statement scoring 1 out of 4. This is also why a practice scoring in the seventies looks green on our reports. It is a pass.

Source: CQC, How we reach a rating.

What CQC actually collects

CQC groups the evidence it looks at into six categories.

1People's experience of health and care services
2Feedback from staff and leaders
3Feedback from partners
4Observation
5Processes
6Outcomes

Source: CQC, Evidence categories. Not every category applies to every statement, and CQC describes the lists as a guide rather than a checklist. Since 2 December 2024 CQC no longer scores at evidence-category level.

What is changing

CQC has said it will remove scoring from its assessment approach, and that future rating judgements will be made holistically using the professional judgement of its inspection teams. It has also said it will no longer make formal judgements below the level of the five key questions.

That changes the method. It does not change what a judgement is made out of.

No final framework has been published and there is no confirmed implementation date for general practice, so the Single Assessment Framework still applies today.

Source: CQC, initial response to the Better regulation, better care consultation. Sector-specific frameworks are in pilot and are not live.

To be clear about what this is. The Auditor gives you our assessment of your evidence against the Single Assessment Framework. It is not a prediction of your CQC rating, and no tool can give you one. What it gives you is an informed, structured view of where you stand while you still have time to act on it.

See what this looks like on a real report

Every quality statement scored, with the reasoning written out.

See a sample report